iBTC pool on Beamswap - Which asset pair?
Ended 1y 7mos ago
closed
Description

One of the next integrations, with the fastest time-to-market, is Beamswap, a DEX on Moonbeam (https://beamswap.io/).

The Beamswap team would like to open an iBTC pool - the question at hand: which asset does the Interlay community want iBTC to be paired with?

There are a few factors to consider, including liquidity, impermanent loss risk, and diversification of integrations.

You can find the top liquid assets on Beamswap here: https://analytics.beamswap.io/tokens

This poll suggests picking one of:

(A) multiUSDC

  • Pros: no 1 in liquidity ($580k), stablecoin.
  • Cons: centralized (Circle), bridge risk (multichain bridge)

(B) GLMR

  • Pros: no 2 in liquidity ($570k), Polkadot native (no bridge risk). Overall high liquidity on Moonbeam
  • Cons: volatile asset, iBTC/GLMR pool already on Stellaswap

(C) multiBUSD

  • Pros: no 3 in liquidity ($370k), stablecoin
  • Cons: centralized (Binance), bridge risk (multichain bridge)

(D) DOT

  • Pros: most liquid asset on Polkadot, used as iBTC collateral, native (no bridge risk)
  • Cons: low liquidity on Beamswap, competes with liquid staking

(E) INTR

  • Pros: Interlay-native pairing, INTR paid to Vaults as rewards, native (no bridge risk)
  • Cons: no liquidity on Beamswap, limited on Moonbeam (needs to come via XCM)

You can vote for one option (your highest preference).

@Vaults / existing iBTC users: Please indicate if you are a Vault / existing iBTC user when you vote. Reason: while all INTR holders can and should vote, it helps to understand the demands of already active iBTC users specifically.

Optionssingle

Votes·34

wdAy...c4oG
wdAy...c4oG
wdAyquMuze7EZrk5pyAv3Vc2Rt1BoL22YBRnZjqSaSQwUc4oG
(D) DOT
# 4
597.63 INTR
wdAm...T1h7
wdAm...T1h7
wdAmi151F5mw4Ex7EybnSoEAZ4LrUbpitm7KTxXcERuuBT1h7
(E) INTR
# 5
4K INTR
Most important pair
wdAJ...u1GG
wdAJ...u1GG
wdAJVgPusG1Fn3buZFzc7JZ3727uwCcEBNLCsU1KaQ8ypu1GG
(B) GLMR
# 2
2.64K INTR
wd9B...grYv
wd9B...grYv
wd9Bhr45eqyRQYQawtjK1J8VALNcvmiHyygikosYqHWL8grYv
(D) DOT
# 4
17.68K INTR
17676
wdAe...GzFZ
wdAe...GzFZ
wdAe2cbTgSjLTwgfFw2cF64yG8FaCT1z8taMkphL4WAHSGzFZ
(D) DOT
# 4
1.78K INTR
10
wd9z...vGzY
wd9z...vGzY
wd9ziEHFLRgpbZioSii3mc7fGu6PNi58aSDB5PZd2ea9wvGzY
(D) DOT
# 4
33.76K INTR
wdAV...svBA
wdAV...svBA
wdAVMK3u56ZbU5R4CAet7e1L62hLxXMX6spF4aTyYqkoEsvBA
(D) DOT
# 4
5.01K INTR
wd8v...ATHb
wd8v...ATHb
wd8vNWUTvofBhcqJQD8puSZneWDrMVYhAUwPZhbLtSSN7ATHb
(D) DOT
# 4
327.48 INTR
wd8Q...Hfvt
wd8Q...Hfvt
wd8Qm97FZTbM8MTTTkRKFrrgkZupQsPWNwEeEmBRSf1GoHfvt
(E) INTR
# 5
509.05 INTR
INTR/iBTC would be "canonical" for Interlay!
wdBi...JDJ9
wdBi...JDJ9
wdBiQZXAvkFS3v1653xXZPvKHyHHYzuU3Xt6GRHtDGdc7JDJ9
(D) DOT
# 4
10.44K INTR
wdCo...kCaZ
wdCo...kCaZ
wdCoPmFYA3wx66jRd6CvexQctK2HZF1uLXCqGxdxAfjzTkCaZ
(A) multiUSDC
# 1
97.58K INTR
wd8M...crGi
wd8M...crGi
wd8Msw8hXJjg7zf1xHCqzwdvstiNxDUDCHyJmuUNZbqiUcrGi
(D) DOT
# 4
9.64 INTR
wd8T...7bW8
wd8T...7bW8
wd8TUhwetqb5575RhVxeG7DzPKWkD6y4EQrheWXVxTrTQ7bW8
(D) DOT
# 4
353.08 INTR
wd8p...vpHC
wd8p...vpHC
wd8pAfEanz6sDrFv3cQZXEHyEFUYZSfPW9bLT8VWksS2AvpHC
(B) GLMR
# 2
491.24 INTR
wdCJ...iips
wdCJ...iips
wdCJerZEKkQg7E18Q5CyomAkU3XZZYt7D6tKxMrqoFFRciips
(D) DOT
# 4
1.32 INTR
wd9N...uNDc
wd9N...uNDc
wd9N5cJa2TXHhiqpQuqYZzH22Qzs81QSxB3QvRSJkSVXFuNDc
(A) multiUSDC
# 1
22.19K INTR
wdDF...csVy
wdDF...csVy
wdDFrF3dp4iaQhzUL44Q4wQfAbL2sWSkXX3WQXzmt7XYTcsVy
(D) DOT
# 4
18.12K INTR
wd9x...MkQz
wd9x...MkQz
wd9xdxPgUyjWd6K5x9U24zK8JKHqY3C1f21KjtFhEE2HxMkQz
(E) INTR
# 5
17.77K INTR
wdAj...uTfv
wdAj...uTfv
wdAj5KyQdK3qxdJrPRyC8F5u2RinkLPBxEKUTCmB11eX9uTfv
(E) INTR
# 5
15.61K INTR
wd9D...rXQo
wd9D...rXQo
wd9Dx3twrhDbPChhLZrEBA9zJGPxA21MvDhXVrRNJaw4zrXQo
(E) INTR
# 5
67.45K INTR
wd9E...dDEB
wd9E...dDEB
wd9E8sVmGmkT4YnD2xgbsoteV4kWgmZZpbZNxexHnee35dDEB
(E) INTR
# 5
42.93K INTR
wd9Q...41Ms
wd9Q...41Ms
wd9QGFDPLPhYUnu4wQN7zRG1HRz1t4rMKeMAYUL7QtqyE41Ms
(D) DOT
# 4
31.73K INTR
Most heavy ecosystem native asset.
wdC4...pycn
wdC4...pycn
wdC4ugMGVhzifo7KCpSrhZyzswpkt75DzWoEUxCjXLaPXpycn
(A) multiUSDC
# 1
27.1K INTR
wd7n...DYfS
wd7n...DYfS
wd7nPmq3aR6oZ9L77gW9XCFUZ19X5v4U3GMv6aYm9bS41DYfS
(E) INTR
# 5
2.99K INTR
wdCm...tn4a
wdCm...tn4a
wdCmDzK89DAvpda8cgBMif6Hx5aZph2s2Y1r4HcLyGTt1tn4a
(D) DOT
# 4
564.76 INTR
wdBK...UXro
wdBK...UXro
wdBKRzWSZSwfeEYRcxS4tj13FvtMJXwzjyFkL9XrxNo5TUXro
(E) INTR
# 5
86.1K INTR
wdBu...PUam
wdBu...PUam
wdBuRbHqyaHVC9rwoZKJZSSNWzuD9YatMb8D4LRgFXrdzPUam
(E) INTR
# 5
53.69K INTR
wdAi...CZ3c
wdAi...CZ3c
wdAiGwBHni7xz4KSYVz7r363EKvrTYyFvSLfiaS9a5qF3CZ3c
(A) multiUSDC
# 1
260.55 INTR
wd7s...kf2w
wd7s...kf2w
wd7s4XgYLMtjF1tJwM697zfamdN1WkAceGjusnAEdT3YPkf2w
(A) multiUSDC
# 1
23.15K INTR
wdB8...Aj7B
wdB8...Aj7B
wdB8Nd7yEB9mkbvCUxp2uEvL29vPHcwQnZBvsBqHwz9U1Aj7B
(A) multiUSDC
# 1
16.32K INTR
wdCM...onYS
wdCM...onYS
wdCM7bThtA4UTnFoMhKCC2YtwJjqE88LMdjhUBPUPeDKconYS
(B) GLMR
# 2
2.53K INTR
wd8K...usSy
wd8K...usSy
wd8KHD9F45AuK7qwj35aYX5tCeLaqn3dvC2n4eM7WEC2jusSy
(E) INTR
# 5
32.37K INTR
wd83...JUK3
wd83...JUK3
wd83WGeFjx2TpUwM9pS72RSvSgpnadgPRboe7BXvMUfceJUK3
(D) DOT
# 4
374.23 INTR
wdD2...KC9K
wdD2...KC9K
wdD2kkzJhBbdL4iu18guouXKGsABT9j5ogBCjQfSB9dNtKC9K
(B) GLMR
# 2
300.28 INTR
1

Discussions·1

1y 8mos ago

Often DEX trading pairs are in a hub-and-spoke arrangement so DEXs can route through hub tokens to exchange two tokens that have no direct trading pair. Incentivizing just an INTR/iBTC pool doesn't accomplish that because INTR doesn't have thick DEX liquidity either. Therefore to reduce trading fees for the INTR token overall I think an INTR/GLMR or INTR/DOT pairing would provide better deep liquidity.

I can understand that vault operators being paid in INTR might want to be able to directly purchase iBTC. But it would remain an isolated pair (INTR/iBTC) not adding a lot of value for general INTR owners. As a vault operator myself, I'd prefer to sell INTR for DOT to put back into the vault to increase my capacity to service more BTC.

1
Information
Snapshot
Assets(1)
INTR
x1
Timestamp
Created
Aug 19 2022 09:48
Start date
Aug 19 2022 09:47
End date
Aug 23 2022 12:00
Results
Voted
636.72K INTR
Voters
34
balance-of
(A) multiUSDC
186.59K INTR
(B) GLMR
5.96K INTR
(C) multiBUSD
0 INTR
(D) DOT
120.74K INTR
(E) INTR
323.42K INTR
Other
0 INTR
quadratic-balance-of
(A) multiUSDC
921.99 INTR
(B) GLMR
141.16 INTR
(C) multiBUSD
0 INTR
(D) DOT
953.24 INTR
(E) INTR
1.57K INTR
Other
0 INTR
© 2024 OpenSquare. All Rights Reserved.