I'm a fan of several sport/esport games, but honestly it won't give me much positive feedback when I see a crypto project besides the logo of Real Madrid or Barcelona.

A very hard call. My first impression is that it is probably the most well-prepared and thought out (e-)sports proposal so far. Looks like Heroic, but done the right way. Heroic was very close to being right. It's a shame they are asking for DOT, hard to understand given the care given to the presentation. It's a nay from me only because it's not asking for stables but DOT.

We will reject all treasury proposals requesting DOT.

the only value i see on this proposal is the fact that they are probably targeting the right people with low resources, gaming is a big market but sponsorships in this market are not.

In general we like to see this. Abstain for us. Could we maybe have them on the Friday call?

No need another esport sponsorship.

I don't think we need another sponsorship in the gaming world.

For this amount, it would be great to lay out a hypothesis for the the customer lifetime value for users brought into Polkadot. For instance, there's a difference between someone downloading Nova to get a prize but then not using the chain on an ongoing basis, and someone who becomes a Dot holder/staker.

I think a sponsorship in the e-sports is only beneficial when Polkadot is active in that space, i.e. games build on or has integrated Polkadot (or any parachain), as Polkadot is not there yet, I think having getting the views or engagement would be futile as there will be very little retention. When the time is right, this organization should definitely be the first call for a sponsorship in my opinion, very good proposal with clear metrics, but ask for stables next time instead of DOT.