[T] DOT #1533 - Faze x Vitality - Esport Meta Proposal.

OpenSquare

Discussions

13zn...P5ju

End

active

Description

https://polkadot.subsquare.io/referenda/1533

A team of 11 people and 7 partners created a proposal for Polkadot.
They believe that Polkadot needs better ways to manage its public actions.
Lots of money is spent to promote Polkadot each year, but much of it goes to waste.
New users often struggle to understand how to interact with Polkadot.
The proposal combines 7 ideas to make Polkadot better and more efficient.
It aims to strengthen partnerships with big esports organizations.
The proposal includes creating new tools and apps to help users.

Cast your votesingle

Votes·4

12Hi...E9N3

12His7t3EJ38tjdBbivUzWQeaNCLKfMqtKp1Ed3xHMyCE9N3

Nay

# 2

My initial position on this one a very strong NAY for a myriad of reasons, please see the discussion below for details.

1ZSP...vx6w

1ZSPR3zNg5Po3obkhXTPR95DepNBzBZ3CyomHXGHK9Uvx6w

Nay

# 2

For a proposal of this magnitude, we don't have an adequate track record of execution, and the treasury is taking too much execution risk, since the funds are delivered upfront. Ideally the esports orgs share in the upfront risk which will align the project for success. Alternately, another path with shared risk and better alignment for success is if the product(s) can be built independently, incubated as a business, and seek out esports organizations as customers or strategic partners.

14gM...deVb

14gMJV95zwxUsFEZDSC8mtBVifS6SypKJkfBKANkMsLZdeVb

Nay

# 2

I don't exposure and marketing is what polkadot need most. The ability to onboard more developers easily is. I see the main direction is contract platform support, infrastructures, developer tools, etc.

14Gn...YLEh

14Gn7SEmCgMX7Ukuppnw5TRjA7pao2HFpuJo39frB42tYLEh

Nay

# 2

I greatly appreciate that people outside Polkadot are interested in building on the network, however, the proposal seems to me overly ambitious and with a very high cost of execution to personally consider an AYE. I would like to see it broken down into clearer, more concise KPIs with more defined timelines, so that I can begin to evaluate the proposal in a more serious way.