Curation request: Multi Genesis
Ended 2y 6mos ago
closed
Description

Multi Genesis includes 1111 generated multi-resource NFTs avatars. Created from over 200 traits. Some traits will be fixed, but most attributes will be equipable.

This is a vetted collection created by 3D artist Cvetommy. Cvetommy is the main creator and founder of Multi Genesis. She is an expert at creating characters and attributes.

She is also the founder of the #multitommy collection, which has been highly regarded by collectors and is in curated collections on the Singular platform.

Multi Genesis link:
Twitter
Singular
Site

#multitommy link:
Singular

Optionssingle

Votes·4

tBZT...35zf
tBZT...35zf
tBZT578GTgFugHGBa4V8tNZ2AwGYXYmKjLsPwJM7Xkc35zf
aye
# 1
p2Nu...DHU9
p2Nu...DHU9
p2NuyPUXfKd7kkLa1EMgyX8Vruvum46pvB9JgJ5Vx57DHU9
nay
# 2
Cj9m...KLUn
Cj9m...KLUn
Cj9mhKTn1odXmXoEHVpcSF3SgHFDD7G69Konh7WFBXYKLUn
aye
# 1
like it
Fr6o...K7A3
Fr6o...K7A3
Fr6ovaQd8ysmjXEF76gQVCErsU8UYzXjYVKV2cTw9myK7A3
nay
# 2
I fail to see what value this collection adds. Maybe I am missing something here but the proposal has little information besides links. I'm not against the project reapplying again in the future but please shed some light here. Upon looking into the collection all I can see is 1111 NFTs with the same artwork and little volume. Upon further review I can see the artwork is to be delivered in the 15th. Maybe it would be better to revisit this for curation when the collection is fully established.

Discussions·1

2y 6mos ago

Based on the criteria set out in the Singular FAQ:

is the collection verified? (see above) - Looks good ✅

does the collection have a banner? - Not that I could find ❌

does the artist have an identity set up in their space? - I would feel better if there was something more than just a Twitter. (not a strong point) ❓

has the artist actively participated in the RMRK protocol with purchases and/or sales? - Hard to judge this one, but I don't see much activity outside your own collections. At least on your minting account

does the artist or the collection have a community existing or growing around it? - Another hard one to judge, there is a decent following on Twitter, but not a lot of engagement with your actual posts. It would help judge the strength of the community if there was a chat room to check for activity. ❌

Skill/Craftsmanship - The NFTs are clearly high quality ✅

Originality - Seems to be original. I assume some research was done before giving the collection Verified status. ✅

Interesting Medium - Seems to be a pretty standard medium to me. ❓

Interesting Project (Well thought-out concept, innovative, etc) - This is a sticking point for me. There doesn't seem to be much explanation of what the project's goals are. From what I can tell it is just another PFP project, which doesn't seem innovative at this point. ❌

General Novelty - The novelty of this project is not clear to me. ❌

Information
Snapshot
Assets(4)
RMRK
x1
RMRK
x1
RMRK
x1
RMRK
x1
Timestamp
Created
May 03 2022 12:25
Start date
May 03 2022 12:24
End date
May 14 2022 21:00
Results
Voted
4.3K RMRK
Voters
4
balance-of
aye
863.95 RMRK
 
nay
3.43K RMRK
 
quadratic-balance-of
aye
41.57 RMRK
 
nay
75.61 RMRK
 
biased-voting
aye
863.95 RMRK
nay
3.43K RMRK
Turnout
4.3K RMRK
Electorate
10M RMRK
StatusSuperMajorityApprove
#1 Failed
StatusSuperMajorityAgainst
#1 Passed
© 2024 OpenSquare. All Rights Reserved.