iBTC pools on Curve and Beamswap - Which token pairs?
Ended 2y 2mos ago
closed
Description

Now that Interlay network and iBTC launch have been completed and we shared a DeFi roadmap overview, we’d like get your input on the next batch of pools we analysed.

The next immediate step is creating a new iBTC pool on Curve and Beamswap, and there’re a couple of combinations to mix and match.

Regarding Beamswap, we launched an off-chain voting poll to gauge your interest and results were aligned with our previous analysis. Results: INTR, DOT, multiUSDC (in that order).

Based on the results, we would like to propose different options for the pools on Curve and Beamswap, as the decision on the token pair for the pool on Beamswap would also impact the pool to be set up on Curve. We have lined up different combinations which we think would be most useful and align with the community vote. Based on internal evaluations and discussions with Beamswap, we suggest the first option, for the reasons we listed below.

--
(1) iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)

Pros:

  • One pool that serves many use cases for all tokens used in the Interlay ecosystem
  • No additional bridging or protocol risk in the Curve pool
  • Meta-pools can be added to the Curve pool that will allow trading of additional assets with that pool without adding any of the mentioned risks to that pool
  • All tokens in the curve pool are available for liquidity provision and the pool as potential to grow with the Interlay ecosystem

Cons:

  • Centralized (Circle), bridge risk (multichain bridge) in the Beamswap pool

--
(2) iBTC/INTR (Beamswap) + iBTC/DOT/USDC (Curve)

Pros:

  • Interlay native tokens only (Beamswap)
  • Polkadot native asset (no bridging risks)

Cons:

  • Centralized (Circle), bridge risk (multichain bridge) in the Curve pool

--
(3) iBTC/DOT (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/USDC (Curve)
Same as for (2) but in a slightly different setup.

--
(4) Other options / None of the above

If you have other options that you would like to propose, please leave a comment in the discussion section with your arguments for that specific option.

Some general comments we would like to share on the pools above:

  • USDC could be replaced by aUSD or USDT, please indicate if other options are preferred
  • Curve pools can be calibrated to have deeper liquidity (less slippage) by design compared to Uniswap V2 like pools
  • Meta-pools can be set up to enable trading between a base pool (e.g. iBTC/DOT/INTR) and another token, without introducing the risk, this token bears, to the base pool. You can find more information on this in the Curve docs.

In addition to the pools above, we are explore the following, which could be added after the execution of the options above, so please leave your feedback on those options in the discussion section:

  • BTC 3pool: iBTC/wBTC/renBTC
  • Polkadot native pool: L1 tokens of large parachains: ACA, GLMR, INTR, PARA, ASTR
Appendants
1
#1
2y ago

Regarding the Curve pools, for both options 2 and 3, the pool will be able to use native USDT available through Statemint and Parity in the next week.

Optionssingle

Votes·16

wdBy...aFCn
wdBy...aFCn
wdByuu2kQ8f4DSn12yZiV5AKurXzTc5yfJyut7nSvpdijaFCn
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
# 1
wdCr...J6t4
wdCr...J6t4
wdCr921vtkTTs2S3wvmbYiHPy1AyRGWKAVfwaiz3zuUx7J6t4
Other options / None of the above
# 4
USDT will be on Dot soon, without bridge
wdCo...kCaZ
wdCo...kCaZ
wdCoPmFYA3wx66jRd6CvexQctK2HZF1uLXCqGxdxAfjzTkCaZ
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
# 1
wd84...1qpo
wd84...1qpo
wd84MQfB7Z7v7VKuWq2tTd6vE6q8nKbFwQCdFuHCiq7hv1qpo
iBTC/INTR (Beamswap) + iBTC/DOT/USDC (Curve)
# 2
wd7s...kf2w
wd7s...kf2w
wd7s4XgYLMtjF1tJwM697zfamdN1WkAceGjusnAEdT3YPkf2w
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
# 1
wdB8...Aj7B
wdB8...Aj7B
wdB8Nd7yEB9mkbvCUxp2uEvL29vPHcwQnZBvsBqHwz9U1Aj7B
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
# 1
wdCr...p1rT
wdCr...p1rT
wdCrbkPfqq1BtPtfCXDkRbfy1vS7SW8KniEwe7iGkngVcp1rT
Other options / None of the above
# 4
I may have chosen with aUSD of course but.... we all know that currently it's on pause :/
wdC3...iekT
wdC3...iekT
wdC32bsYJvU74v3hyKQU3sMp9REZYcShL11b81SoNBk4RiekT
iBTC/DOT (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/USDC (Curve)
# 3
wdAJ...u1GG
wdAJ...u1GG
wdAJVgPusG1Fn3buZFzc7JZ3727uwCcEBNLCsU1KaQ8ypu1GG
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
# 1
wd9R...QJZe
wd9R...QJZe
wd9R3jm7J9cbvRzAJoqAaHTSyETArBVtbHDmAXb5t6fPWQJZe
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
# 1
100
wd9R...VeEa
wd9R...VeEa
wd9R7mh97vpVysrhd2knXtVBUTELFU2TB1HUhyJkCtwPGVeEa
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
# 1
wd8v...ATHb
wd8v...ATHb
wd8vNWUTvofBhcqJQD8puSZneWDrMVYhAUwPZhbLtSSN7ATHb
Other options / None of the above
# 4
wdAy...c4oG
wdAy...c4oG
wdAyquMuze7EZrk5pyAv3Vc2Rt1BoL22YBRnZjqSaSQwUc4oG
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
# 1
wdAd...U5JF
wdAd...U5JF
wdAdcy8wkpzAPFrehVhZc7yS2u1Pmi4jE7kgPNbwnT6TcU5JF
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
# 1
wdA5...CADg
wdA5...CADg
wdA5P9YUUqrfWSbnQg5egscavax4zHfKn3JzHRjV1zTu3CADg
Other options / None of the above
# 4
wd8K...usSy
wd8K...usSy
wd8KHD9F45AuK7qwj35aYX5tCeLaqn3dvC2n4eM7WEC2jusSy
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
# 1

Discussions·0

No current comments
Information
Snapshot
Assets(1)
INTR
x1
Timestamp
Created
Aug 26 2022 16:33
Start date
Aug 25 2022 23:00
End date
Sep 01 2022 23:00
Results
Voted
266.42K INTR
Voters
16
balance-of
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
227.08K INTR
 
iBTC/INTR (Beamswap) + iBTC/DOT/USDC (Curve)
152.99 INTR
 
iBTC/DOT (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/USDC (Curve)
225.14 INTR
 
Other options / None of the above
38.96K INTR
 
quadratic-balance-of
iBTC/USDC (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/DOT (Curve)
1.2K INTR
 
iBTC/INTR (Beamswap) + iBTC/DOT/USDC (Curve)
12.37 INTR
 
iBTC/DOT (Beamswap) + iBTC/INTR/USDC (Curve)
15 INTR
 
Other options / None of the above
340.14 INTR
 
© 2024 OpenSquare. All Rights Reserved.